Has there ever been a 5–4 in MLS?

Yes, 13 times.

The first time: April 24, 1998, Colorado Rapids beat Chicago Fire (Colorado Rapids 5–4 Chicago Fire).

The last time: September 5, 2026, Portland Timbers beat Minnesota United (Portland Timbers 5–4 Minnesota United).

Home wins: 8. Away wins: 5.

Nearby scores

1. 6–3 6 times
2. 6–4 4 times
3. 6–5 Never
4. 5–3 26 times
5. 5–4 13 times
6. 5–5 1 time
7. 4–3 128 times
8. 4–4 18 times

All games

1. September 5, 2026 Portland Timbers 5–4 Minnesota United
2. September 13, 2025 Atlanta United 4–5 Columbus Crew
3. August 2, 2022 New York Red Bulls 4–5 Colorado Rapids
4. April 24, 2022 New York City FC 5–4 Toronto FC
5. July 17, 2021 CF Montréal 5–4 FC Cincinnati
6. May 10, 2014 New York Red Bulls 4–5 Chicago Fire
7. September 27, 2008 New York Red Bulls 4–5 Colorado Rapids
8. August 18, 2007 New York Red Bulls 5–4 LA Galaxy
9. May 20, 2006 New York Red Bulls 5–4 Chivas USA
10. September 17, 2005 New York Red Bulls 5–4 New England Revolution
11. June 2, 2002 Chicago Fire 5–4 Columbus Crew
12. June 6, 1998 D.C. United 4–5 FC Dallas
13. April 24, 1998 Colorado Rapids 5–4 Chicago Fire