Has there ever been a 9–5 in MLS?

Never.

It would be a scorigami. Based on the average number of goals in MLS, the chance of a game ending 9–5 is about 1 in 2,006,928.

Nearby scores

1. 10–4 Never
2. 10–5 Never
3. 10–6 Never
4. 9–4 Never
5. 9–5 Never
6. 9–6 Never
7. 8–4 Never
8. 8–5 Never
9. 8–6 Never