Has there ever been a 9–3 in the Premier League?

Yes, 3 times.

The first time: October 3, 1891, Darwen beat Stoke City (Darwen 9–3 Stoke City).

The last time: December 8, 1934, Derby County beat West Bromwich Albion (Derby County 9–3 West Bromwich Albion), 91 years ago.

Home wins: 3. Away wins: 0.

Nearby scores

1. 10–2 Never
2. 10–3 2 times
3. 10–4 1 time
4. 9–2 7 times
5. 9–3 3 times
6. 9–4 Never
7. 8–2 16 times
8. 8–3 6 times
9. 8–4 2 times

All games

1. December 8, 1934 Derby County 9–3 West Bromwich Albion
2. October 17, 1931 Everton 9–3 Sheffield Wednesday
3. October 3, 1891 Darwen 9–3 Stoke City